(Circulation. 1995;91:2961-2971.)
© 1995 American Heart Association, Inc.
Articles |
From the Departments of Pharmacology (J.J.C., G.R.S., M.J.M.), Biological Chemistry (B.B., C.C., J.A.S., R.J.G., T.M.C.), and Medicinal Chemistry (D.-M.F., R.F.N.), Merck Research Laboratories, West Point, Pa.
Correspondence to Jacquelynn J. Cook, PhD, WP42-300, Merck Research Laboratories, West Point, PA 19486.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and Results The immune IgG (IgG 9600) inhibited
thrombin-stimulated aggregation and secretion of human platelets. In
contrast, it had no effect on platelet activation induced by other
agonists including ADP, collagen, or the thrombin receptorderived
peptide SFLLR-NH2. IgG 9600 also inhibited thrombin-induced
aggregation of African Green monkey (AGM) platelets. By Western blot
analysis, the IgG identified a protein of
64 kD in homogenates
of both human and AGM platelets. The effect of thrombin receptor
blockade by this antibody on arterial thrombosis was evaluated in an in
vivo model of platelet-dependent cyclic flow reductions (CFRs) in the
carotid artery of the AGM. The intravenous administration of IgG 9600
(10 mg/kg) abolished CFRs in three monkeys and reduced CFR frequency by
50% in a fourth monkey. Ex vivo platelet aggregation in response to up
to 100 nmol/L thrombin was completely inhibited during the 120-minute
postbolus observation period in all four animals. There was a twofold
increase in bleeding time, which was not statistically different from
baseline, and ex vivo clotting time (APTT) was not changed. The
glycoprotein IIb/IIIa receptor antagonist MK-0852 and the thrombin
inhibitor recombinant hirudin also demonstrated inhibitory effects on
CFRs at doses that did not significantly prolong template bleeding
time. Control IgG had no effect on CFRs, ex vivo platelet aggregation,
bleeding time, or APTT.
Conclusions These results demonstrate that blockade of the platelet thrombin receptor can prevent arterial thrombosis in this animal model without significantly altering hemostatic parameters and suggest that the thrombin receptor is an attractive antithrombotic target.
Key Words: platelets thrombosis antibodies
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Damaged vessel walls and exposed mural thrombi are sites of thrombin generation and of residual adsorbed thrombin.13 Thrombin is naturally inhibited by endogenous antithrombin III, and this reaction is enhanced by heparin14 ; however, heparin is not always efficacious in animal models of thrombosis.15 16 17 18 19 The lower efficacy of heparin may reflect its inability to catalyze the inactivation of clot-bound thrombin by antithrombin III. There are also other inhibitors of thrombin including small molecule catalytic site inhibitors,20 the leech protein hirudin,21 and hirulog, a hybrid comprised of the C-terminal domain of hirudin and the active sitedirected inhibitor D-Phe-Pro-Arg.22 Hirudin and these small molecule inhibitors have been shown to be antithrombotic, eliminating thrombus formation in animal models of deep arterial injury, arteriovenous shunts, electrolytic injury, venous stasis, disseminated intravascular coagulation, and restenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty.15 16 17 18 19 23 24 25 26 However, a potential limitation to the use of hirudin or the low-molecular-weight inhibitors is that at a concentration that is effective in these models, primary hemostasis could be compromised since clotting time or template bleeding time are prolonged.16 17 24 25 The direct thrombin inhibitors, recombinant hirudin (r-hirudin) and Hirulog, have also demonstrated efficacy in preliminary human trials. r-Hirudin showed benefit over heparin in angiographic improvement of the arterial lesion in unstable angina,27 and Hirulog used as adjunctive therapy to streptokinase significantly improved the early patency rate of the infarct-related artery.28 It is not known if efficacy of the thrombin inhibitors is due primarily to their prevention of thrombin-mediated fibrin formation or of platelet activation or if inhibition of both is required. The lack of a potent and selective inhibitor of each of these processes has not allowed this question to be addressed.
We prepared neutralizing antibodies against the cloned thrombin receptor, characterized their activity against human and monkey platelets, and evaluated their effect in the model29 of cyclic flow reductions (CFRs), which was modified for use in the carotid artery of the African Green monkey.30 In this model, under conditions of arterial stenosis and endothelial injury, platelets adhere to exposed subendothelium and blood flow gradually declines as an intravascular thrombus forms. This provided an animal model of arterial thrombosis for investigation of the in vivo role of thrombin-stimulated platelet activation. The effect of thrombin receptor blockade on CFRs, platelet aggregation, bleeding time, and clotting parameters was evaluated and compared with that of blockade of platelet aggregation with a glycoprotein IIb/IIIa inhibitor, MK-0852, and the thrombin inhibitor r-hirudin. The current results indicate an important role for the thrombin receptor in promoting thrombus formation in this model.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Antibody Preparation
New Zealand White
rabbits were immunized with the 15-residue
peptide KYEPFWEDEEKNESC-NH2 conjugated to either rabbit
serum albumin or keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) via the terminal
cysteine. This receptor peptide corresponds to amino acid residues 51
to 64 of the thrombin receptor, TR,51-64 thought to
represent a thrombin binding site31 plus an
additional carboxy terminal cysteine for coupling. The bleeds were
screened initially by ELISA assay against both conjugated peptides,
nonconjugated peptides, and irrelevant peptides. IgG from the
ELISA-positive sera were isolated using protein G kits and evaluated as
inhibitors of thrombin-stimulated platelet aggregation. Immune IgG from
the rabbit, which was the most potent inhibitor of platelet
aggregation, was purified on a larger scale on both protein G and
protein A sepharoses for use in the in vivo studies. The isolated IgGs
were evaluated as inhibitors of thrombin-stimulated platelet
aggregation and secretion.
Production of Peptides and Other
Platelet Inhibitors
Thrombin receptor peptides were synthesized as
previously
described.32 The crude peptide products were purified by
preparatory high-performance liquid chromatography on a DELTA-PAK
C18 column. Fractions containing product of at least 99%
purity were combined and characterized for amino acid composition after
6N HCl acid hydrolysis. Peptides synthesized as carboxyl terminal
amides are indicated by the symbol (-NH2). The fibrinogen
receptor antagonist MK-0852 was prepared as described,33
and r-hirudin was expressed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae
yeast and isolated as previously described.34
In Vitro Assessment of Antiplatelet Activity
Platelet
Aggregation and Secretion
Blood was collected from healthy human
volunteers free of
aspirin and other drugs for at least 8 days into 3.8% trisodium
citrate anticoagulant (1:10). The erythrocytes and white cells were
sedimented from the whole blood and separated from the platelet-rich
plasma by centrifugation. Platelets were isolated from the plasma by
differential centrifugation and then were washed in a modified
Tyrode's buffer (5 mmol/L HEPES, 0.3 mmol/L
NaH2PO4, 3 mmol/L KCl, 134 mmol/L NaCl,
5 mmol/L glucose, 2 mmol/L MgCl2, 12 mmol/L
NaHCO3, pH 6.5) containing 1 mmol/L EGTA, 20 mg/mL
apyrase, and 3.5 mg/mL bovine serum albumin as previously
described.35 The final platelet suspension was at
2x108 platelets per milliliter in the same buffer at pH
7.4 without EGTA.
Characterization of the effect of the thrombin receptor IgG on platelet aggregation was carried out in 96-well plates (an assay developed by B. Bednar, C. Condra, R.J. Gould, and T.M. Connolly to measure platelet aggregation in a 96-well microplate reader). Briefly, the washed platelets with 0.2 mg/mL human fibrinogen were incubated with the IgG for 30 minutes at room temperature. Thrombin was added to the platelets, and they were agitated. Platelet shape change and aggregation were monitored as a decrease or increase in light transmittance, respectively, in a Vmax microplate reader. The amount of light transmittance (extent of aggregation) or the rate of change of light transmittance (rate of aggregation) of the samples incubated with the immune IgG was compared with that of both untreated control samples and samples treated with preimmune IgG. Secretion was monitored as the release of platelet-dense granule [3H]-serotonin in response to thrombin, as previously described,35 with a minor modification. The current assays were carried out in 100 µL in 96-well plates rather than in tubes, and correspondingly smaller aliquots were used for radioactivity determinations.
Aggregation of platelets from African Green monkeys was carried out in platelet-rich plasma as previously described35 or in a whole blood assay36 according to the following procedure. Blood was collected into 3.8% trisodium citrate anticoagulant (1:10). For the in vitro studies, 0.4 mL of blood was incubated for 30 minutes with immune IgG or vehicle at room temperature. The treated blood was then transferred to a stirring (1000 rpm) aggregometer at 37°C and incubated for 3 minutes with 4 mmol/L H2N-Gly-Pro-Arg-Pro-OH peptide to prevent thrombin-mediated fibrin polymerization.37 Thrombin was added to the stirred sample, and after an additional 4 minutes, the cuvette was removed and a platelet count was determined with an automated hematology analyzer (Serono-Baker Diagnostics). A decrease in the number of single platelets was used to measure the extent of platelet aggregation. Preliminary results with this method were comparable to those seen with the measurement of platelet aggregation by light transmittance in platelet-rich plasma. Ex vivo platelet aggregation was carried out using the same method as described for in vitro aggregation; the response to increasing concentrations of thrombin (5 to 100 nmol/L) was tested at each time point.
In Vivo Assessment of Antiplatelet Activity
All procedures
used in this study were conducted according to
the principles of the American Physiological Society and were approved
by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at Merck Research
Laboratories, West Point, Pa.
Surgical Preparation
African Green monkeys of either sex weighing 3.4 to 6.7 kg were
sedated with ketamine HCl (10 mg/kg IM) and anesthetized with sodium
pentobarbital (12.5 mg/kg IV). After intubation for mechanical
ventilation with room air and vessel cannulation (right femoral artery
for continuous monitoring of hemodynamic parameters and blood
collection, right femoral vein for supplemental anesthesia, and left
femoral vein for compound administration), animals were surgically
prepared for CFRs. Supplemental anesthesia was administered
intravenously as needed (0.2 to 0.4 mL, 65 mg/mL sodium pentobarbital).
A 4-cm segment of the left carotid artery was isolated and instrumented
from proximal to distal with a flow probe (Doppler to measure blood
flow velocity or electromagnetic, Carolina Medical Instruments, to
measure blood flow), a Lexan or silver clip constrictor, and a snare
ligature. Physiological parameters were recorded on a model 7D
polygraph (Grass Medical Instruments). The vessel lumen was constricted
such that mean blood flow was reduced an average of 60%, and the
phasic pattern was nearly abolished; endothelial damage was induced by
repetitively pinching the vessel from the outside. The accumulation of
platelet aggregates in the vessel lumen was observed as a gradual
reduction in blood flow. When flow reached its lowest level, the
platelet plug was mechanically dislodged, and carotid arterial blood
flow was restored. When using the silver clip, the clip was adjusted if
necessary to ensure that the maximal blood flow that was established at
the start of the protocol was not exceeded. The cyclical pattern of
flow reductions was repeated for the duration of the protocol or until
disrupted by an effective antithrombotic agent. Beginning at 60
minutes after administration of each agent, the vessel was redamaged at
15-minute intervals by pinching with a hemostat to ensure exposure of
thrombogenic subendothelium. CFRs were monitored for 120 minutes after
administration of each agent to determine the duration of in vivo
antithrombotic effect.
Experimental Protocol
After
instrumentation, the vessel was allowed to
equilibrate for a minimum of 30 minutes before initiating CFRs. After
15 minutes of consistent CFRs, the vehicle was administered, and 15
minutes later, the test treatment was begun (time 0). MK-0852 (3
µg/kg+1
µg · kg-1 · min-1 or 10
µg · kg+3
µg · kg-1 · min-1)
and r-hirudin (0.5 mg/kg+0.015
mg · kg-1 · min-1) were both
given as
a bolus followed by a 60-minute infusion, and the control IgG and the
thrombin receptor antibody IgG 9600 were given as a bolus (10 mg/kg). A
blood sample was taken before the initiation of CFRs for platelet
aggregation and activated partial thromboplastin time (APTT)
measurements, and control bleeding time was determined. During CFRs,
these same parameters were measured after the administration of the
vehicle and at 30-minute intervals (for 120 minutes) after the
intravenous bolus infusion of the test compound: r-hirudin, MK-0852,
thrombin receptor antibody (IgG), or control rabbit IgG. This protocol
is summarized in Fig 1
. Ex vivo platelet aggregation was
performed as described above.
|
Bleeding Time Determinations
Template bleeding times were measured with a SIMPLATE bleeding
time device (Organon Teknika Corporation). A sphygmomanometer was
placed on the upper arm and inflated to 40 mm Hg; uniform incisions
were made on the muscular area of the forearm, and the duration of
bleeding was measured to a maximum of 15 minutes.
Activated
Partial Thromboplastin Time
APTT values were determined as an
indication of the function of
the intrinsic clotting factors using an automated clot timer (Electra
900, Medical Laboratory Automation) and commercially available reagents
(American Dade) according to the protocol provided by the
supplier.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
8 µg/mL IgG, as shown in Fig 2B
64-kD
protein as the prominent band, as shown in Fig 3
|
|
Since the
major goal of our studies was to use the antibody as a
receptor-specific tool in in vivo studies, it was necessary to
determine if it cross-reacted with platelets from other species
commonly used in thrombosis studies. As human thrombin
receptorderived ligand peptides are able to promote full aggregation
of platelets only from primates and guinea
pigs,32 40 41
we first studied the interaction of this antibody with platelets from
these species. Antibody 9600 identified a protein in African Green
monkey whole platelet homogenates in Western blotting that was the
same size as that from human platelet homogenates, as shown in Fig
3
.
This antibody also inhibited thrombin-stimulated platelet aggregation
in African Green monkey platelet-rich plasma (Fig 4A
).
As with human platelets, this IgG had no effect on the platelet
aggregation response to ADP, collagen, or a thrombin receptor
activating peptide (TRAP) (Fig 4A
). IgG 9600 was next tested to
see if
it inhibited thrombin-induced aggregation of African Green monkey
platelets in whole blood. As shown in Fig 4B
, this antibody
completely
inhibited aggregation induced by up to 100 nmol/L thrombin. In contrast
to this result with monkey platelets, antibody 9600 did not block the
aggregation of platelets from the guinea pig. Therefore, the species
cross-reactivity in Western blots and in the functional assays
suggested the use of antibody IgG 9600 in a thrombosis model in the
African Green monkey.
|
In Vivo Model of Thrombosis in the African Green Monkey
IgG
9600 was compared with a potent and specific platelet
inhibitor, MK-0852,33 and with the active sitedirected
thrombin inhibitor r-hirudin in a model of CFRs in the African Green
monkey (Table 1
). The GPIIb/IIIa receptor antagonist was
studied for comparison, since it had previously demonstrated efficacy
in a variety of thrombosis models including the model of CFRs and the
more severe electrolytic injury model, both in the canine coronary
artery.42 For the purposes of the present study,
MK-0852 was tested with two dosing regimens: 10 µg/kg IV bolus+3
µg · kg-1 · min-1 for 60
minutes
(10+3, n=3) and 3 µg/kg IV bolus+1
µg · kg-1 · min-1 for 60
minutes
(3+1, n=3). At the higher dose, CFRs were abolished immediately
after
bolus administration and remained inhibited throughout the infusion in
all animals, as shown in Fig 5
. The baseline pattern of
CFRs returned in an average of 51 minutes after the end of the
infusion. Although the ex vivo platelet aggregation response to
thrombin was only modestly reduced at the 1-minute postbolus time point
(data not shown), it was completely inhibited at 60 minutes (end) into
the infusion of MK-0852 (Fig 5
). At the 120-minute time point
(60
minutes after the end of the infusion), the ex vivo response to
thrombin was similar to the pretreatment response, which corresponded
with the return of intravascular thrombus formation (CFRs). The
administration of a lower dose of MK-0852 (3+1) resulted in an initial
prolongation of the CFR cycle length, and only by the end of the
60-minute infusion were CFRs abolished (data not shown). At the end of
the lower-dose MK-0852 infusion, ex vivo thrombin-induced platelet
aggregation was only partially inhibited in response to 20, 50, and 100
nmol/L thrombin; the response was about 50% of the response to these
concentrations of thrombin in the pretreatment sample. In comparison,
at the same time point, the response to thrombin was completely
inhibited by the higher dose of MK-0852. CFRs returned in 27 minutes
after the end of the lower-dose MK-0852 infusion, which is more rapid
than with the higher dose (51 minutes).
|
|
The effect of direct thrombin
inhibition was also investigated in this
model using r-hirudin (0.5 mg/kg+0.015
mg · kg-1 · min-1 for 60
minutes).
CFRs were immediately abolished after the administration of the bolus
in all four monkeys, remained inhibited during the infusion, and
returned to the baseline pattern of cyclical flow reduction in an
average of 93 minutes (n=4) after the end of the infusion. Ex vivo
platelet aggregation induced by all concentrations of thrombin was
inhibited at 1, 30, and 60 minutes after the r-hirudin bolus. The ex
vivo response to thrombin partially returned by 120 minutes (60 minutes
after the end of the infusion), as aggregation was observed in response
to the highest thrombin concentrations tested (50 and 100 nmol/L). Fig
6
shows a representative blood flow tracing
demonstrating the inhibition of CFRs after r-hirudin administration and
the inhibition of thrombin-induced aggregation at the end of the
60-minute infusion.
|
The demonstration of efficacy with the GPIIb/IIIa
antagonist MK-0852
confirmed the contribution of platelets to the development of CFRs and
the inhibitory effect of r-hirudin identified a role for thrombin in
this model of intravascular thrombosis. However, the effect of
selective blockade of the platelet thrombin receptor remained to be
investigated. IgG 9600 as an intravenous bolus at 10 mg/kg clearly
showed activity in all four monkeys in which it was tested. It
immediately and completely inhibited CFRs in three of the four animals
and reduced by 50% the CFR frequency in the final monkey. Fig 7
shows baseline CFRs and the immediate abolition of this
intravascular event in response to the thrombin receptor antibody in a
representative monkey. In the three animals in which CFRs were
abolished, there was no return of thrombus accumulation, as evidenced
by flow reduction for 120 minutes after the bolus was given despite
repeated vessel redamage over the last 60 minutes. In addition, the
50% reduction in CFR frequency in the fourth monkey persisted for the
entire 120 minutes of observation. Ex vivo thrombin-induced platelet
aggregation was completely inhibited at 30, 60, 90, and 120 minutes
after the administration of the bolus at all concentrations of thrombin
(5 to 100 nmol/L). The mean ex vivo platelet aggregation response to
thrombin (n=4) is also shown in Fig 7
for samples taken
at the
60-minute postbolus time point. Normal rabbit IgG had no significant
effect on any of the parameters measured (see Fig 8
). In
addition, after the vehicle infusion at the start of each experiment,
no changes were observed in CFR pattern or frequency, and the ex vivo
response to thrombin was not altered. Table 1
summarizes the
effect of
all treatments on CFRs.
|
|
Effect of Inhibitors on Hematologic Parameters
Bleeding times
and clotting times expressed as APTT are summarized
for all experimental groups in Table 2
. These values
represent measurements from the 60-minute postdrug
administration (bolus or end of infusion) time point and
represent the peak effect for each treatment and correspond to
the time period of observed in vivo intravascular effects. The higher
dose of the fibrinogen receptor antagonist MK-0852 (10+3) caused a
prolongation of bleeding time of 6.5-fold, while the APTT was not
affected by this treatment. With the low dose of MK-0852 (3+1), the
bleeding time was only slightly increased (1.5-fold), and the APTT was
not altered. Immediately after the initial bolus of r-hirudin, APTT was
at least eightfold greater than baseline. However, APTT values rapidly
decreased to a fourfold elevation at 5 minutes after the bolus and were
maintained at that level for the duration of the infusion. Bleeding
time was only slightly prolonged, 1.4-fold above baseline, at 60
minutes after the end of the r-hirudin infusion. With antibody 9600, at
the 60-minute postbolus time point, bleeding time was only moderately
elevated (twofold) and APTT was not affected. Normal rabbit IgG had no
effect on bleeding time or clotting time.
|
Although MK-0852, r-hirudin, and control IgG had no significant effect on whole blood platelet count, a gradual decrease was observed after the intravenous bolus administration of IgG 9600. The mean platelet count±SEM (1000/µL) before administration of this antibody was 279±11, and the postdose values were as follows: 30 minutes, 256±14; 60 minutes, 233±15; 90 minutes, 230±10; and 120 minutes, 225±10 (n=4). Although the 17% and 19% decreases at 90 and at 120 minutes, respectively, were only modest, they were statistically different (P<.05, ANOVA followed by Dunnett's multiple comparison) from the baseline platelet count. The platelet counts during the initial observation of the in vivo antithrombotic effect promoted by IgG 9600, at 30 and 60 minutes after the administration of the antibody, however, were not significantly reduced from pretreatment values.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The antibody against the cloned thrombin receptor that was used in the current study inhibited both secretion and aggregation of human platelets stimulated by thrombin but not by ADP, collagen, or a thrombin receptor agonist peptide. Thrombin-induced platelet aggregation was inhibited by this antibody in several primate species, including the African Green monkey, but not in a variety of nonprimate species. Therefore, a model of arterial thrombosis in the African Green monkey was selected for this study. In this model, CFRs are experimentally induced in stenosed and deendothelialized carotid arteries. This repetitive pattern of flow reduction has been characterized both histologically29 and pharmacologically45 46 as a predominantly platelet-dependent phenomenon. Adherent platelets present on the damaged endothelium and platelet aggregates comprise a significant portion of the formed thrombi in the lumen of the constricted and injured vessel.47 48 Interruption of CFRs has been shown in the canine coronary artery with numerous antiplatelet agents including aspirin, prostacyclin, thromboxane synthetase inhibitors, thromboxane A2 receptor antagonists, the 5-HT antagonist ketanserin, and the glycoprotein IIb/IIIa (GPIIb/IIIa) inhibitor MK-0852.42 48 Efficacy was also demonstrated with the monoclonal antibody directed against the platelet GPIIb/IIIa receptor 7E3 in the carotid artery49 50 and by thromboxane receptor antagonism in the renal artery30 51 of the cynomolgus monkey. The thrombin inhibitor MCI-9038 was reported to interrupt CFRs early (30 minutes) but not late (3 hours) after induction in the dog.52 Hirulog, a synthetic, hirudin-based, thrombin-inhibitory peptide, prevented thrombotic arterial occlusions in the carotid artery of the pig.19 However, therapeutic anticoagulant levels of the antithrombin IIIdependent thrombin inhibitor heparin were less effective in inhibition of CFRs than direct thrombin inhibitors.19 46 Although both platelet inhibitors and thrombin inhibitors have demonstrated efficacy in this model, it has not yet been shown if blockade of the specific interaction between thrombin and platelets would also be effective.
Based on results of previous studies with antiplatelet and antithrombin agents, we selected doses of MK-0852, the platelet GPIIb/IIIa antagonist, and r-hirudin that either completely inhibited ex vivo ADP-induced platelet aggregation42 or elicited a three- to fourfold increase in APTT,19 respectively. These levels were previously shown to be necessary to achieve in vivo antithrombotic activity in animal models of arterial thrombosis. The administration of both MK-0852 and r-hirudin resulted in the inhibition of intravascular thrombus formation. The in vivo efficacy demonstrated by MK-0852 and r-hirudin therefore established that both platelet aggregation and thrombin activity play a significant role in the intravascular event that results in the cyclical pattern of flow reduction in this model. The thrombin receptor antibody IgG 9600 provided us with a specific tool to investigate the potential contribution of the platelet thrombin receptor, as opposed to all thrombin-mediated events, to arterial thrombus formation in the monkey. This thrombin receptor antibody showed complete and immediate abolition of CFRs in three of the four monkeys. Activity was also evident in the fourth animal, as CFR frequency was reduced by 50%. IgG 9600 also prevented the return of thrombus formation in response to increasing intimal damage in all monkeys. In addition, this antibody completely inhibited the ex vivo platelet aggregation response to all concentrations of thrombin at all time points. These results demonstrate that the thrombin receptor on platelets plays a significant role in the thrombotic event that leads to flow reduction in this model.
The relation between the effects on CFRs and ex vivo platelet aggregation was not the same for all agents tested. The inhibition of the ex vivo response to thrombin was more pronounced in the higher-dose MK-0852 group than in the lower-dose group at the end of the infusion (60 minutes). Platelet aggregation in response to lower thrombin concentrations (5 to 20 nmol/L) was inhibited by both dosing regimens, but the higher concentrations of thrombin (50 and 100 nmol/L) were only completely inhibited in the higher-dose MK-0852 group. However, CFRs in all animals in both groups were abolished at this same time point (60 minutes). This suggests that thrombin may not be present locally in the artery at the concentrations represented by the higher concentrations on the thrombin curve or that some intermediate effect by MK-0852 on the inhibition of thrombin-induced platelet aggregation is sufficient to prevent the intravascular event. Since the thrombin concentration in a human thrombus that develops over an extended period of time has been determined to be approximately 100 nmol/L,53 it is conceivable that the local thrombin concentration in the thrombus formed acutely in this model might be <100 nmol/L. A similar dissociation of the effect on the inhibition of CFRs and on ex vivo aggregation was previously reported with antibodies directed against the platelet GPIIb/IIIa receptor.49 Abolition of platelet thrombus formation in the carotid artery of the cynomolgus monkey was achieved at doses that did not abolish ex vivo platelet aggregation.49 Alternatively, ex vivo aggregation in response to thrombin can be inhibited without in vivo efficacy in the model of CFRs in the African Green monkey carotid artery. Other antibodies were raised against the thrombin-binding exosite and the tethered ligand region of the cloned thrombin receptor that were less potent inhibitors of in vitro thrombin-induced human platelet aggregation than IgG 9600. In preliminary experiments, two of these other antibodies were administered to the African Green monkey at the same dose as the dose of IgG 9600 used in the current studies. Although they reduced ex vivo thrombin-induced platelet aggregation, they did not inhibit CFRs in the carotid artery (data not shown). The relationship between ex vivo platelet aggregation and in vivo CFR production remains to be established.
The results of the effect of the four different treatment groups on primary hemostasis indicate that in vivo antithrombotic activity can occur at doses that do not elevate template bleeding time. Although the higher dose of MK-0852 (10+3) produced a peak prolongation of bleeding time of 6.5-fold over baseline, the lower dose (3+1) was also fully efficacious, and bleeding time was only extended 1.5-fold. The maximum prolongation of bleeding time in the r-hirudintreated group was 1.75-fold and was observed immediately after the initial loading bolus; APTT values suggest that plasma levels of r-hirudin peaked at this time point. During the interruption of CFRs by r-hirudin, bleeding time was not different from pretreatment. As mentioned above, the thrombin receptor antibody IgG 9600 showed complete inhibition of CFRs at a dose that increased bleeding time only twofold. In addition, there was no observation of excessive surgical bleeding or rebleeding from previous hemostatic plugs in the group of monkeys receiving antibody IgG 9600. Previous studies by other investigators using a GPIIb/IIIa antibody50 or a thromboxane receptor antagonist51 did not report bleeding time or had difficulty in obtaining reproducible results with forearm template bleeding time measurements. However, in the present study, pretreatment bleeding times were extremely consistent, as were peak bleeding times in response to the various treatments. Baseline bleeding times in all groups were 1.0 to 1.5 minutes, and these did not change during the administration of vehicle or control IgG. A significant effect was observed with the higher dose of the GPIIb/IIIa inhibitor MK-0852, and the time course of the prolongation of bleeding time correlated with the time course of the inhibition of ex vivo thrombin-induced platelet aggregation. With this higher dose of MK-0852, bleeding time was elevated 1.7-fold at 1 minute after the bolus and start of infusion, along with a slight inhibition of platelet aggregation. The effect on bleeding time and the inhibition of aggregation both increased at 30 minutes (4.7-fold increase in bleeding time) and again at 60 minutes (6.5-fold increase in bleeding time) after the start of the infusion and returned toward baseline 60 minutes after the end of the infusion (2.5-fold increase in bleeding time). In addition, the peak effect of r-hirudin on bleeding time occurred concomitantly with the peak effect on APTT. The effect of IgG 9600 on ex vivo platelet aggregation induced by thrombin was the same as that of the higher dose of MK-0852; however, the thrombin receptor antibody elicited a mean (n=4) maximal effect on bleeding time of 2.8-fold increase at 120 minutes after bolus administration. The results of these various treatments indicate that the procedure used for bleeding time measurement in this study was sensitive enough to identify actual effects on this measure of hemostasis and that the thrombin receptor antibody did not significantly alter this critical parameter. Similarly, in a subsequent study, the GPIIb/IIIa antibody mentioned above was shown to inhibit intravascular thrombus formation at a dose that had only modest effects on bleeding time using an alternate, reproducible method for determination of bleeding time.49
It is not known if the dose of IgG 9600 used in the present study is the minimally efficacious dose. Due to the limited supply of this antibody, we were not able to study a range of doses and therefore do not know if a lower dose would be sufficient for the activity observed. It is also impossible to predict if the efficacious dose, which did not suggest bleeding complications, would be sufficient for activity in other animal models. A higher dose of this antibody might be necessary for antithrombotic activity in more severe models, and the effect of other doses on primary hemostasis is unknown. Additional antibodies have been prepared, and these questions will be addressed in subsequent studies.
A moderate and gradual decrease (17% at 60 minutes and 19% at 120 minutes) in whole blood platelet count was observed over time after the bolus administration of the thrombin receptor antibody IgG 9600. This effect was not protocol related, as it was not observed in any other treatment groups. It also does not appear to be a nonspecific effect of IgG, since platelet count did not change in the control IgG group. The inhibition of CFRs occurred immediately after antibody administration; however, the platelet count was not significantly changed from pretreatment values until 90 minutes later. A reduction in platelet count, even to the level of thrombocytopenia, is not unprecedented by molecules that bind to platelet receptors. For example, administration of a monoclonal antibody against the platelet GPIIb/IIIa complex to the baboon resulted in a significant reduction in platelet number.54 In addition, administration of a von Willebrand fragment that binds to the platelet glycoprotein Ib receptor produced a transient but significant decrease in platelet number in the cynomolgus monkey.55 The effect on platelet number in the present study is less pronounced than that observed in those studies. The time course of the return of platelet count to normal after IgG 9600 administration is not known, since it was not observed by the end of this acute protocol. Thrombocytopenia could potentially present a bleeding risk to the patient; therefore, the safest antagonist of this receptor for clinical use would be one that did not typically reduce circulating platelet number.
In summary, an antibody that blocks the 7-transmembrane thrombin receptor was effective in prevention of intravascular thrombus formation in the model of CFRs, modified for use in the carotid artery of the African Green monkey. At an efficacious dose of IgG 9600, in which ex vivo platelet aggregation induced by thrombin was completely inhibited, this antibody did not alter coagulation time (APTT) and had little effect on bleeding time. MK-0852 and r-hirudin were also effective in this model in the absence of significant prolongation of bleeding time. These results demonstrate that blockade of the platelet thrombin receptor prevents arterial thrombus formation in a primate model of arterial thrombosis without altering hemostatic parameters and that efficacy can be achieved without inhibiting the enzymatic activity of thrombin for fibrinogen. Prevention of platelet secretion by blockade of the platelet thrombin receptor also gives this mechanism a potential advantage over inhibition of the GPIIb/IIIa receptor. Since thrombin contributes significantly to platelet recruitment at sites of vascular injury, blockade of the thrombin receptor on platelets is an attractive antithrombotic mechanism.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received October 17, 1994; revision received November 28, 1994; accepted December 3, 1994.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-thrombin-catalyzed conversion of plasma levels of fibrinogen to
fibrin in the presence of antithrombin III. J Biol
Chem. 1991;266:13003-13010. This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
K. W. Ward, D. J. Coon, D. Magiera, S. Bhadresa, E. Nisbett, and M. S. Lawrence Exploration of the African Green Monkey as a Preclinical Pharmacokinetic Model: Intravenous Pharmacokinetic Parameters Drug Metab. Dispos., April 1, 2008; 36(4): 715 - 720. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. J. Leger, L. Covic, and A. Kuliopulos Protease-Activated Receptors in Cardiovascular Diseases Circulation, September 5, 2006; 114(10): 1070 - 1077. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
V. Schulte, H. P. Reusch, M. Pozgajova, D. Varga-Szabo, C. Gachet, and B. Nieswandt Two-Phase Antithrombotic Protection After Anti-Glycoprotein VI Treatment in Mice Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol., |