(Circulation. 1995;92:196-201.)
© 1995 American Heart Association, Inc.
Articles |
From the Departments of Cardiology (G.D., A.C., B.L.) and Cardiothoracic Surgery (D.M.S., J.P.B., R.S.), Research Group Vacomed, Hôpital Charles Nicolle, Centre Hospitalier et Universitaire de Rouen, France, and the Departments of Cardiology (G.H., P.A., R.L.) and Cardiothoracic Surgery (D.M.), Hôpital de la Timone, Centre Hospitalier et Universitaire de Marseille, France.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and Results Transesophageal echocardiography (TEE) was performed in 75 patients with Sd HT and in 20 patients with Tot HT. Despite the use of antiplatelet therapy, an acute arterial embolism occurred in 11 (15%) of the 75 patients with Sd HT but in none of the 20 Tot HT patients. All patients were in sinus rhythm. Left ventricular ejection fraction was similar in Sd HT and Tot HT patients. Left atrial diameter was smaller in Tot HT patients than in Sd HT patients (41±4 versus 58±6 mm, P<.001). In Sd HT patients, spontaneous echo contrast was present in 43 patients (57%) and was associated with left atrial thrombus in 20 patients (on the left atrial appendage in 12 patients, on the posterior wall in 6, and on the suture in 2). No thrombus was detected by transthoracic echocardiography; all thrombi were detected by TEE. On the other hand, no left atrial thrombus was observed in Tot HT patients, and only 1 patient had spontaneous echo contrast. Of the 11 Sd HT patients who experienced an arterial embolism, 5 had both spontaneous echo contrast and left atrial thrombus and 5 had only spontaneous echo contrast.
Conclusions This study demonstrates a high rate of left atrial thrombus after Sd HT and emphasizes the role of TEE in the follow-up of these patients. The therapeutic implications are the need for a preventive anticoagulant therapy in the high-risk population receiving Sd HT diagnosed with TEE and the consideration of Tot HT as a better surgical approach as far as thrombotic complications are concerned.
Key Words: transplantation echocardiography thrombosis surgery atrium
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
However, recent transesophageal echocardiographic studies2 3 4 have pointed out anatomic and physiological imperfections of this technique because it leads to enlarged resultant atria and therefore promotes stasis and atrial thrombosis.
Dreyfus et al5 and Banner et al6 have proposed an alternative technique of orthotopic heart transplantation, the "total" atrioventricular transplantation, in which complete excision of the recipient's atria is undertaken to allow atrial as well as ventricular transplantation.
The aim of this study was to compare, by the use of transthoracic and transesophageal echocardiography, the standard orthotopic heart transplantation with the total atrioventricular transplantation.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All patients received immunosuppressive therapy including cyclosporine, azathioprine, and prednisone in addition to antiplatelet therapy (250 mg aspirin in 51 patients and 300 mg dipyridamole in 44 patients). No patient had evidence of rejection at endomyocardial biopsy performed on the same day as echocardiography. Written, informed consent was obtained from all the patients for the study.
Echocardiography
Transthoracic and transesophageal
echocardiography were performed with an Acuson XP
128 echocardiograph (Acuson Inc) equipped with a 2- to
2.5-MHz phased-array transducer for transthoracic
echocardiography and a high-frequency biplane
phased-array transducer for transesophageal
echocardiography. Transthoracic
echocardiography enabled measurements of cardiac
chamber size (left atrial, left ventricle end-systolic and
end-diastolic diameters). Left atrial diameter was
obtained by taking the mean of three different measurements: the first
by the M-mode echocardiogram recorded in the parasternal
short-axis view at end systole and the second and third
measurements obtained from the horizontal and vertical left atrial
sizes in the two-dimensional apical four-chamber view. Left
ventricular ejection fraction was calculated using the
single-plane area-length method. Transmitral pulsed Doppler
flow echocardiography enabled measurements of
transmitral flow velocities: early (E) and late (A) peak velocities and
their subsequent ratio, E/A, as well as the isovolumetric relaxation
time.
Transesophageal echocardiography was carried out after lidocaine pharyngeal anesthesia and intravenous midazolam had been administered, with no complications or failures. Both atria, interatrial septum, and left atrial appendage were carefully scanned. Color flow Doppler echocardiography was used to detect and quantify valvular regurgitation and interatrial shunt. Contrast solution was infused during a Valsalva maneuver to detect patent foramen ovale.
Spontaneous echo contrast (SEC) was defined as the presence of swirling smokelike echoes within the atrial cavity, with appropriate gain settings to distinguish SEC from echoes due to excessive gain. SEC was subgrouped into marked and mild, marked SEC being an intense echo visible in the entire left atrium at a normal gain level and mild SEC a discrete echo occupying some parts of the left atrium at a high gain level.7
All echocardiograms were reviewed by two independent observers to determine the presence or absence of SEC and left atrial thrombi. Differences in interpretation were resolved by consensus. Thrombi were considered to be present only when the images depicted as thrombi were clear, obvious, and unquestionable for both the observers.
In cases of total heart transplantation, particular attention was paid to the vascular anastomoses: superior and inferior venae cavae and pulmonary vein anastomoses were carefully scanned. When the region of anastomosis was identified, systematic evaluation with color and pulsed Doppler echocardiography was performed to detect any stenosis.
Hemodynamic Data
Endomyocardial biopsy and right heart
catheterization were performed on the same day as
transesophageal echocardiography in
68 of 75 patients in group A and 12 of 20 patients in group B. Right
heart pressures including right atrial, right ventricular,
pulmonary arterial, and pulmonary capillary
wedge pressures were measured by a Swan-Ganz thermodilution catheter
that was introduced via right jugular puncture. Cardiac output was
determined by thermodilution method, and the mean of five successive
measurements was taken.
Statistical Analysis
All values were expressed as
mean±SD. ANOVA was used to compare
subgroups of patients with mild SEC, marked SEC, and without SEC. An
unpaired Student's t test was used to compare the two
groups of patients with and without thromboembolic complications. A
value of P<.05 was considered statistically significant.
Multiple logistic regression analysis (maximal likelihood ratio
method) was used to determine independent predictors of SEC and left
atrial thrombus in the entire population; the presence of SEC or atrial
thrombus served as dependent variables, whereas left atrial size
(
55 mm), recipient age (
55 years), time elapsed since
transplantation (
6 months), left ventricular ejection
fraction (
55%), and number of previous acute rejection episodes
(
2) were used as independent variables.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Despite the use of antiplatelet therapy in all patients since their surgeries, an acute arterial embolic event occurred in 11 (15%) of the 75 enrolled patients of group A, who received standard orthotopic transplants (0.42 embolic events per patient and per month or 3.5% embolic events per patient and per year), but in none of the 20 patients of group B, who received total atrioventricular transplants. The overall incidence of arterial embolization in the total population transplanted (185 patients) over the entire time period was 5.9%. At the time these embolic events occurred in group A patients, the mean time elapsed since transplantation had been 22±23 months: 5 embolisms within the first 6 months, 3 embolisms within the first 2 years, and 3 embolisms during the fourth year after transplantation. These embolic events consisted of 6 strokes, 3 lower limb artery embolisms, and 2 mesenteric artery embolisms. Because of the embolic events, these 11 patients underwent transesophageal study and were subsequently started on oral anticoagulant therapy.
Transthoracic
Echocardiography
Baseline transthoracic
echocardiographic characteristics of patients of groups
A and B are listed in Table 1
. Left ventricular size and
ejection fraction were similar in both groups. However, the left atrial
diameter was markedly greater in patients of group A (58±6 versus
41±4 mm; P<.001). On Doppler
echocardiography, a normal and regular pattern of
left ventricular filling was seen on the Doppler mitral
flow in group B patients with normal E and A waves, whereas Doppler
mitral flow showed great variations from cycle to cycle in group A
patients, reflecting the asynchronous atrial
electrophysiological activity. SEC and left
atrial thrombus were not detected by transthoracic
examination and were found only by transesophageal
echocardiography.
Presence of SEC
The presence of SEC was documented by
transesophageal echo in the left atrium of 43 of 75
patients (57%) who received standard transplantation (group A).
However, SEC was observed in only 1 of the 20 patients who had total
transplantation (group B) (P<.001). Patients in group A
were divided into three subgroups: no SEC (32 patients), presence of
mild SEC (31 patients), or presence of marked SEC (12 patients) (Table
2
). There was no significant difference among the three
subgroups regarding recipient or donor age, left
ventricular ejection fraction, hemodynamic
data, and particularly the time from transplantation. Left atrial
diameter was slightly but significantly greater in patients with mild
(59±5 mm) and marked (61±5 mm) SEC than in patients with no SEC
(56±5 mm, P<.02 mild SEC subgroup versus no SEC subgroup
and P<.001 marked SEC subgroup versus no SEC subgroup).
|
To reduce the discrepancy between group A and group B concerning time elapsed from transplantation, we compared the transesophageal studies performed within the first postoperative year in 26 patients in group A (mean time since standard transplantation, 9±3 months) and in 19 patients in group B (mean time since total transplantation, 5±4 months). The incidence of SEC was 61% (16 of 26 patients) in group A, whereas it was 5% (1 of 19 patients) in group B.
Left Atrial Thrombus
Left atrial thrombi were observed by
transesophageal echo in both the transverse and
longitudinal views in 20 of 75 patients (27%) of group A. No thrombi
were found in the 20 patients of group B. The thrombi were localized in
the donor left atrial appendage in 12 patients, on the posterior wall
of the left atrium in 6 patients, and on the suture in 2 patients. They
occurred only in patients who showed SEC (5 thrombi among the 12
patients with marked SEC and 15 thrombi among the 31 patients with mild
SEC). No such thrombi were observed in the 32 patients who had no SEC.
Baseline characteristics of the patients in group A with and without
left atrial thrombus are listed in Table 3
. The two
subgroups of patients were not statistically different except for the
cardiac index, which was significantly lower in patients with left
atrial thrombus (2.75±0.5 versus 3.1±0.6
L · min-1 · m-2,
P<.05), and for time since heart transplantation, which was
significantly higher in patients with left atrial thrombus (34±26
versus 24±16 months, P<.05). When only the patients
studied during the first postoperative year were considered, a left
atrial thrombus was found in 23% of patients in group A (6 of 26
patients) and in none of the patients in group B.
|
Multiple logistic
regression analysis was used to compare left
atrial diameter, time elapsed since transplantation, recipient age,
left ventricular ejection fraction, and number of previous
acute rejection episodes concerning their value for identification of
patients with SEC or left atrial thrombus among the entire population,
and selected left atrial diameter (
55 mm) as the only independent
predictor (P<.001) (adequacy of fit via
2 P=.653).
Association of SEC and Left Atrial Thrombus to Thromboembolic
Episodes
Eleven patients among the 75 patients in group A (15%) had a
previous history of arterial embolism, but none of the 20
patients in group B had such history. Because of the embolic events,
these 11 patients received oral anticoagulant therapy. SEC was
present in 10 of these 11 patients (mild in 6, marked in 4), and
left atrial thrombus was detected in 5 of these patients (4 in the left
atrial appendage and 1 on the posterior wall). There was no significant
difference between patients in group A with or without thromboembolism
regarding the recipient or donor age, time from transplantation, left
atrial diameter, left ventricular ejection fraction, or
hemodynamic data (Table 4
).
|
Other Abnormalities
The atrial septum was perfectly
visualized in all the patients by
transesophageal echo. Two cases of atrial septum
aneurysm were found: one in group A that was associated with
mild SEC in a patient who had had a stroke 12 months after surgery and
the other in a patient in group B. A patent foramen ovale was found on
the donor component of the interatrial septum after contrast infusion
in 7 patients in group A. The left atrial suture line was found to be
particularly prominent at the left atrial free wall in most patients
(mean length, 11±3 mm). This protruding suture line just above the
left atrial appendage created a niche on which 7 of the 12 thrombi
located in the left atrial appendage were found. Protruding
atherosclerotic plaques were observed in the aortic arch of 2 patients:
1 patient in group A who also had had mild SEC and presented
with a stroke 3 years after surgery and 1 in group B. Mitral
regurgitation was a frequent finding (55 of 75 patients
in group A and 15 of 20 in group B) and was graded as mild in most of
them, except that in 1 patient with standard transplantation it was
graded as moderate. Mild tricuspid regurgitation was
detected in all of the patients. Scanning of the vascular anastomoses
in group B was easy for left pulmonary veins and superior vena
cava that we examined in all the patients. We could locate the
inferior vena cava anastomoses in only 5 patients and the
right pulmonary vein anastomoses in only 11 patients. In no
case did we detect either stenosis or thrombus on the site of
the vascular anastomoses in group B patients.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The atrial anatomic changes that result from standard orthotopic heart transplantation in our patients lead to pathological consequences such as a high incidence of SEC and of atrial thrombi that correspond to a high embolic event rate in this group of patients. These abnormalities could be found only by transesophageal study that we routinely perform in our two institutions within the first year after heart transplantation. SEC was found in 57% (43 of 75) of our patients transplanted by the standard technique and in only 5% (1 of 20) of our patients transplanted by the total atrioventricular technique. A left atrial thrombus was found in 20 of the 75 patients with the standard technique, associated with SEC in all patients, and in none of the 20 patients with the total transplantation technique. It is very unlikely that this marked difference in the incidence of SEC and left atrial thrombosis between the two techniques can be explained by the longer time elapsed from transplantation to the transesophageal study because SEC and left atrial thrombus were also found frequently (61% and 23%, respectively) in the 26 patients with standard transplantation enrolled within the first postoperative year.
Until now, there has been little information on the incidence of both SEC and atrial thombosis after heart transplantation despite the large number of heart transplants worldwide, with a long follow-up. The frequency with which SEC and thombi are detected by transesophageal echocardiography has been reported in previous studies but from small series of heart transplant patients operated on by the standard method. Among a population of 20 heart transplant recipients, Angermann et al2 described SEC in 5 patients (25%) and a left atrial thrombus in 3 patients (15%) with 1 of these 3 patients having a peripheral arterial embolism. Polanco et al3 found a higher incidence of SEC (47%) in a study of 30 heart transplant recipients, all of whom were receiving antiplatelet therapy but no anticoagulant therapy. Thrombus formation occurred in only 2 patients (6%) in this series and was detected by both transthoracic and transesophageal studies: one was localized in the right atrium and the other was in the left atrium, which embolized, caused obstruction of the left ventricular outflow tract, and led to the patient's death.
Our findings from this larger series confirm these previous reports and emphasize the important role of early transesophageal echocardiography in the detection of atrial thrombus, which involves a high risk of acute arterial embolism in heart transplant recipients. The reasons for the formation of SEC and left atrial thrombi after standard transplantation are still a matter of debate, since heart transplant atria constitute a unique example of anatomic substrate of SEC and atrial thrombosis without the usually involved factors that favor atrial thrombosis, such as mitral valve stenosis, prosthetic mitral valve, left ventricular dysfunction, or atrial fibrillation.8 9 10 11 Other than the anatomic substrates for the atrial thrombi formation (such as enlarged left atrium and prominent suture line), there could be several other factors that may be involved (ie, intracardiac hemodynamic alterations caused by the asynchronous contractions of the recipient and donor atrial components, the presence of arrhythmias either in the course of an acute rejection episode or preexisting in the recipient atrial component, and possibly alterations in hemostasis such as an increased platelet aggregation related to inhibition of the endothelial prostacyclin synthesis mediated by cyclosporine).12
This comparative study between two surgical techniques clearly emphasizes the important role of the surgical technique since thromboembolic complications occurred only after standard transplantation and not after total transplantation. However, no data are yet available that follow patients who have received total transplantation for more than 6 months, especially for the incidence of complications such as stenosis or thrombus on the site of vascular anastomoses.
In our series, an arterial embolism was documented in 11 of the 75 patients receiving standard transplantation (15%) enrolled for transesophageal study. This high rate of embolic events is questionable and may be explained by the fact that these 11 patients had a transesophageal echocardiogram for the purpose of looking for a cardiac source of embolism and were therefore included in the study. Moreover, it must be noted that the overall incidence of arterial embolism was 5.9% (11 of the 185 patients) in the total group of heart transplant recipients from both our two institutions) and 9% when we considered all the patients who had had a standard heart transplantation (11 of 122 patients). However, ischemic or anoxic changes, including cerebral infarcts, were found during more than 60% of 31 postmortem examinations in heart and heart-lung transplant recipients.13 Andrews et al14 reviewed the neurological complications that occurred among a series of 90 patients treated with standard orthotopic cardiac transplantation and found that within the first 60 days of postoperative care, 2 patients (2%) had suffered ischemic cerebral infarctions that could be related to an emboli from cardiac origin.
In our series, we decided to use oral anticoagulant therapy in the patients who had a definite left atrial thrombus. However, we chose not to institute oral anticoagulant therapy in patients with isolated spontaneous contrast in their left atria despite a few studies that have suggested that the presence of atrial smoke identifies patients at an increased thromboembolic risk.7 9 We think that more data are necessary from heart transplant recipients to determine whether spontaneous contrast is associated with a higher rate of atrial thrombus. Our data also demonstrate that transesophageal echocardiography is the procedure of choice for the evaluation of both SEC and left atrial thrombi. At the present time, we perform routine transesophageal echocardiography in all heart transplant recipients 6 months after surgery; however, since the first thromboembolic episode occurred within the first month after transplantation, we may consider performing transesophageal echocardiography before discharging the patient, at 1 month after transplant.
Limitations of the Study
Because of the recent introduction
of this surgical technique, the
number of patients with total transplantation was smaller than that of
patients with standard transplantation, and the follow-up was
clearly shorter. Larger series with longer follow-up times would
therefore be necessary to enable one to draw conclusions on the
potential complications of this new technique, to make sure that no
late formation of thrombus could occur (particularly on the site of
anastomoses), and to establish the true benefits of total
transplantation as regards the rate of thromboembolic
complications.
Conclusions
The initial technique of orthotopic heart
transplantation
introduced by Shumway and coworkers is the most commonly used. However,
the prominent sutures at the site of atrial anastomoses, the
enlargement of the resultant atria, and also the asynchronous
contraction of the recipient and donor atria contribute to explain the
high incidence of atrial thrombus in these patients, thereby
necessitating consideration of oral anticoagulant therapy in the group
of patients with left atrial thrombus. On the other hand, total
orthotopic heart transplantation seems from this preliminary report to
avoid these thromboembolic complications, and therefore, although
technically more demanding, it should become the operative procedure of
choice if our results are confirmed in larger series.
| Footnotes |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Circulation Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 1995 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |