(Circulation. 1996;93:301-309.)
© 1996 American Heart Association, Inc.
Articles |
From the Division of Hematology and Oncology, Department of Medicine, and Yerkes Regional Primate Research Center, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Ga; and the Molecular Hematology Branch (D.A.D.), National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, Bethesda, Md.
Correspondence to Laurence A. Harker, MD, Division of Hematology and Oncology, Emory University School of Medicine, PO Drawer AR, Atlanta, GA 30322.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and Results Cultured baboon ECs transduced with human
cDNAs for wild-type tissue plasminogen
activator (TPA) or for
glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchored urokinase-type
plasminogen activator (a-UPA) were seeded onto
collagen-coated segments of vascular graft (collagen segments)
and exposed overnight to flow using an in vitro perfusion circuit. The
antigenic levels of TPA and UPA each increased 10-fold in the media
perfusing the corresponding transduced ECs compared with untransduced
ECs (P
.05 in both cases). In baboons the antithrombotic
effects of TPA-transduced or a-UPAtransduced ECs were measured
as 111In-platelet deposition and
125I-fibrin accumulation on collagen segments bearing
sparsely attached ECs (transduced versus untransduced) interposed in
exteriorized arteriovenous femoral shunts. Platelet-rich
thrombus formed on the collagen segments with fibrin-rich thrombus
propagated distally. The presence of TPA-transduced or
a-UPAtransduced ECs on collagen segments at a density of 25 000
ECs/cm2 decreased 111In-platelet
deposition and 125I-fibrin accumulation on collagen
surfaces compared with untransduced ECs present at equivalent
density (P<.05 for platelet deposition with
TPA-transduced ECs and P<.05 for platelet deposition on
the propagated tail, as well as fibrin accumulation on the graft with
a-UPAtransduced ECs). The systemic levels of
fibrinopeptide A, thrombin-antithrombin complex,
D-dimer, and both local and systemic levels of TPA and UPA
were not increased by transduced ECs compared with untransduced ECs.
The focal antithrombotic effects of transduced ECs appear to be due to
local enhancement of thrombolysis.
Conclusions ECs transduced with recombinant TPA and a-UPA enhance local antithrombotic activity in vivo. This strategy of attaching transduced ECs overexpressing plasminogen activators may be therapeutically useful by preventing thrombo-occlusive failure of implanted cardiovascular devices or mechanically denuded vessels.
Key Words: plasminogen activators thrombosis endothelium
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The development of techniques for transferring and expressing genes at high efficiency in ECs12 13 permits testing the hypothesis that increased EC expression of specific antithrombotic or fibrinolytic genes reduces thrombus formation in vivo. Previous publications report the attachment of retroviral-transduced ECs onto denuded arterial surfaces14 15 or prosthetic devices deployed in vitro13 16 17 and in vivo.18 Human plasminogen activator genes also have been transferred and overexpressed in ovine, bovine, and baboon ECs in vitro.19 20 21 22 In the present study, the antithrombotic effects of ECs transduced with plasminogen activator genes were assessed in a quantitative model of thrombosis in baboons.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the present experiments, the continued production of high levels of recombinant TPA and UPA antigen by the transduced cells was confirmed by collecting conditioned medium from an in vitro perfusion apparatus containing segments of collagen-coated vascular graft to which transduced ECs were attached (see below). Medium was assayed for TPA and UPA antigen with ELISAs. These ELISAs detect both human and baboon plasminogen activators and appear to do so with similar efficiency (American Diagnostica).22 Baboon plasma from in vivo experiments was assayed for TPA and UPA antigen with the same ELISAs used for in vitro experiments.
Labeling of Endothelial Cells
Confluent cell cultures in T25
flasks were washed free of
proteins with 37°C DPBS. The flasks were incubated for 10 minutes
with 5 mL 111In-oxine containing 1x107
cpm/mL in RPMI-1640HEPES medium.24 25 After
withdrawing
excess unbound 111In-oxine, each flask was washed once
with warm DPBS and incubated overnight in 5 mL of complete culture
medium. This procedure ensured the functional recovery of the labeled
cells and achieved consistent labeling of approximately 1 to 2
cpm/cell at the time cells were used in experimental protocols.
Preparation of Thrombogenic Graft Segments
To assemble
thrombogenic segments of vascular graft
material,26 27 Gore-Tex vascular grafts (WL Gore
Inc),
5-µm pore, 4-mm internal diameter, were threaded over 4-mm Teflon
rods and stabilized in configuration and diameter by encasement in
sleeves of "heat-shrink" Teflon tubing (Small Parts, Inc).
The encased grafts were then cut into 1-cm lengths and connected with
12-cm-long and 7-cm-long segments of silicone rubber tubing,
4-mm internal diameter, abutted at each end and encompassed in
heat-shrink Teflon. Care was taken to avoid junctional
irregularities in the flow surface. These graft segments were
autoclaved at 250°F for 25 minutes and maintained sterile thereafter.
Before their use in experiments, the luminal surfaces of the graft
segments were wetted by instilling 95% ethanol into the circuit for 20
minutes, followed by flushing with sterile water (500 mL) to remove all
ethanol from the system.
The resultant segments of Gore-Tex graft were coated with collagen to create a smooth thrombogenic luminal surface. To accomplish this, the circuit was charged with an acidic buffer (Horme buffer, pH 2) followed by the addition of 100 µL of 1 mg/mL equine collagen solution (Horme AG) into the lumen of each 1-cm-long graft segment. The segments then were incubated at room temperature for 2 hours, followed by air drying for 1 hour, using sterile air flowing through the tubing. Subsequently, the collagen solution (100 µL) was again introduced into the graft lumen and incubated overnight, followed by air drying. These collagen-coated segments then were incubated with human fibronectin (Biomedical Technologies Inc; 20 µg/100 µL) for 1 hour, with subsequent final air drying. In the experiments described, the completed sterile collagen segments were prewarmed to 37°C before introducing cultured ECs.
Endothelial Cell Attachment to Collagen
Segments
To increase the probability of discriminating between the
antithrombotic effects of plasminogen
activators overexpressed by transduced ECs versus
plasminogen activators constitutively expressed
by untransduced ECs, we compared direct measurements of platelet
and fibrin accumulation on collagen segments bearing ECs at
subconfluent densities. Subconfluent endothelial
coverage permitted thrombus to form on exposed intervening collagen
while assuring direct contact of EC-secreted plasminogen
activators with forming thrombus.
111In-labeled ECs were
washed twice with 0.2 mg/mL EDTA
in PBS and removed from the culture flask by trypsin digestion (0.05%
trypsin in EDTA). Trypsin was inactivated by adding FCS.
The labeled EC suspension was diluted to 50 mL with DPBS,
centrifuged at 200g for 15 minutes, then gently
resuspended in DPBS at 105 cells/100 µL. The specific
activity of the cell suspension was determined using gamma
scintillation counting (Packard Instrument Co) and electronic cell
counting (Serono/Baker). The lumen of each graft segment was filled
with 100 µL cell suspension per 1 cm of graft using a long, 16-gauge
needle. Grafts were maintained at 37°C and rotated 90° each minute
for 30 minutes to obtain an even distribution of attached ECs.
Unattached cells then were removed by flushing the graft lumen with 1
mL DPBS. This procedure produced a graft surface bearing ECs attached
at a density of approximately 25 000 cells/cm2 (Fig
1
). This density of attached ECs was shown to be
suitable in a series of preliminary experiments using untransduced ECs.
In these studies, sensitivity was compromised by either increasing EC
density to 50 000/cm2, in which case there was
reciprocal reduction in baseline thrombus formation, or decreasing EC
density to 10 000/cm2, in which case there was no
detectable thrombolysis (data not shown).
|
The graft segments bearing
attached ECs were incorporated into an in
vitro perfusion circuit maintained at 37°C (Fig 2
).
This system consisted of a microcarrier spinner flask, 100-mL size
without the stir-paddles (Dow-Corning, Inc), containing
approximately 30 mL of culture medium that was equilibrated with 5%
CO2 in air. This gas mixture was humidified and injected
through a 0.22-µm pore-sterilizing filter via the spinner flask
portal. Inflow and outflow of culture medium was performed through the
two sidearms of the flask via silicone rubber tubing at a flow rate of
15 mL/min by roller pump, beginning 2 hours before interposing the
cell-attached graft segments and continuing for 16 hours
thereafter.
|
Three to five graft segments seeded with aliquots of the same type of ECs (untransduced, TPA-transduced, or a-UPAtransduced) were perfused in series and imaged together with a standard of 111In-labeled ECs of known concentration. After calculating the density of attached ECs on each segment, segments bearing approximately 25 000 attached ECs/cm2 were selected for subsequent studies in vivo; the remaining segments were discarded. In this way, comparisons of different types of ECs were performed at equivalent EC density. Before dismantling the perfusion apparatus and removing the segments, samples of the perfusate were collected for assaying TPA or UPA antigen. The perfusate then was displaced by DPBS, and the grafts were maintained at 37°C with warmed gel packs during transport and manipulation before incorporation into exteriorized AV shunts.
Preparation of Animals for In Vivo Studies
Normal male
juvenile baboons (Papio anubis) weighing
9 to 11.5 kg were used in these experiments. All procedures were
approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee in
compliance with the National Institutes of Health guidelines
(Guide For the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals, 1985),
Public Health Service policy, the Animal Welfare Act, and related
university policies. The baboons were observed to be disease free for
at least 3 months before in vivo studies were performed.
For surgical procedures, animals were given ketamine hydrochloride (20 mg/kg IM) for induction, 1% halothane by endotracheal tube for anesthetic maintenance, and buprenorphine (0.01 mg/kg every 8 hours as needed) for postoperative analgesia. Thereafter, ketamine hydrochloride (5 to 20 mg/kg IM) was used for subsequent short-term immobilization in performing experimental procedures.
Chronic exteriorized AV access shunts were surgically placed between the femoral artery and vein to permit interposition of thrombogenic graft segments and blood sampling. The shunts were composed of silicone rubber tubing, 3.0-mm internal diameter (Silastic, Dow Corning Corp). The arterial and venous arms of the shunt were connected with 1-cm-long, blunt-edge PTFE tubing (2.8-mm inner diameter). These chronic AV shunts do not detectably activate platelets or fibrinogen.28 29 30
The thrombogenic collagen segments24 26 31 were interposed into exteriorized AV shunts of awake animals, and blood flows in the AV shunts were maintained at 40 mL/min by measuring flow with a C-clamptype ultrasonic flow probe interfaced with a Transonic T206 blood flow analyzer. Initially, experiments were performed with unseeded collagen segments. Subsequently, a series of paired morning/afternoon experiments was performed comparing collagen segments bearing LtSN-transduced versus untransduced ECs. Paired segments were placed sequentially in the same baboon (one segment in the morning and another in the afternoon), but with the order of the segments varied among animals. Analogous experiments compared collagen segments bearing LUK+ASN-transduced versus untransduced ECs.
Assays of Blood and Plasma Hemostatic and Fibrinolytic
Factors
Blood counts and hematocrits were measured on whole blood
collected in EDTA (2 mg/mL) with the use of a Serono/Baker model 9000
whole blood analyzer. Plasma fibrinogen concentrations were
measured as thrombin-clottable protein using the method described
previously.30 31 32
Blood samples were taken before and after each experiment and evaluated for platelet counts, plasma levels of fibrinogen, TPA, UPA, FPA, platelet factor 4, ß-thromboglobulin, TAT, and fibrinolytic product D-dimer.27 These blood tests of fibrinolytic and hemostatic function were performed on plasma samples obtained before placing the thrombogenic devices (t=0 minutes, baseline), and repeat tests were performed on blood samples drawn at the end of the experiments (t=60 minutes). At 60 minutes, samples were also obtained proximal and distal to the devices for assaying TPA and UPA antigen.
In Vivo Measurements of Thrombus Accumulation
Thrombus
accumulation on collagen segments was quantified by
measuring the deposition of platelets and fibrin. Autologous baboon
platelets were labeled with 1 mCi 111In
(111In-oxine, as previously described26 )
and reinjected at least 1 hour before incorporation of thrombogenic
devices in the AV shunts. Labeling efficiencies averaged 90%.
111In-labeled platelets were functionally
normal.26 28 Baboon fibrinogen was purified by
ß-alanine precipitation and labeled with 125I with
use of the ICI method as described previously30 33 ;
labeling efficiency averaged 70%, yielding >90% clottable
fibrinogen. A 5-µCi dose of 125I-labeled fibrinogen was
injected intravenously 10 minutes before interposing the
device in the AV shunt.
Images of the collagen segments, including proximal and distal segments of the AV shunts, were acquired with a General Electric 400T MaxiCamera and stored and analyzed with a Medical Data Systems A3 image processing system (Medtronic) interfaced with the camera.26 The low energy peak (172 KeV) of 111In was imaged with a 10% energy window. Dynamic images were acquired at 5-minute intervals. Immediately after each dynamic study, standards were imaged, including a syringe containing 5.0 mL of whole blood (blood standard) and an identical thrombogenic device filled with static autologous blood (device standard). The imaging routines and isotopic detection protocols for these shunt studies used procedures reported previously.24 28 31 32 Studies of individual grafts in awake animals were terminated after 60 minutes by agreement with the Animal Care and Use Committee because previous studies showed that thrombus formation in this model generally reached a steady state at this time.26 32 33
The thrombus consisted of two regions of interest that were analyzed separately, that is, the platelet-rich thrombus on collagen segments, analyzed over 1 cm (8x10-pixel region of interest), and the propagated fibrin-rich tail, analyzed over a length of 10 cm (80x10-pixel). The total number of deposited platelets in each region (labeled plus unlabeled platelets) was calculated, as described previously.32 All blood radioactivity measurements were corrected for the small fraction of nonplatelet isotope in each experiment. 111In-platelet emissions were counted to measure thrombus formation. For this measurement, emissions from both the graft and the fibrin-rich tail regions of the experimental device were counted. Deposited 111In-labeled platelet activity was calculated by subtracting the device standard activity from each region of interest.
To measure fibrin in platelet- and fibrin-rich thrombi, after completion of the experiment, the device was thoroughly washed with isotonic saline solution. The vascular graft thrombus then was divided from the propagated tail for separate counting of 125I emissions. These emissions were counted at least 30 days after the study to allow for the decay of 111In activity (half-life, 2.8 days). Total fibrin deposition was calculated by dividing the deposited 125I-fibrin activity (counts per minute) by the clottable fibrinogen activity (counts per minute per milliliter) and multiplying by the plasma fibrinogen level (milligrams per milliliter).
Statistical Analysis
Data are presented as mean±1 SD
unless indicated
otherwise. Significance was generally determined with use of the
Student's t test, unpaired, two-tailed
analysis, except for data not normally distributed, when
nonparametric analyses were performed. Paired,
two-tailed analysis was used to compare platelet and
fibrin deposition on the grafts and in the propagated tails (InSTAT,
GraphPAD software). The curves comparing platelet deposition were
analyzed for significance by repeated measures ANOVA (SYSTAT,
Inc).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
In Vivo Effects of Endothelial Cells on
Thrombus Formation
Before initiating in vivo studies comparing the
effects of
untransduced and transduced ECs, the accumulation of
111In-platelets and 125I-fibrin on
collagen segments alone without attached ECs was measured during 60
minutes of blood flow in exteriorized AV shunts. Platelets and
fibrin accumulated rapidly on these unseeded collagen segments,
reaching a plateau value by 60 minutes of
3.20±1.09x109
platelets and 1.14±0.83 mg fibrin. Propagated thrombotic tails
extending downstream from these unseeded collagen segments accumulated
10.8±5.26x109 platelets and 1.94±1.40 mg
fibrin.
To compare the antithrombotic effects of untransduced ECs to ECs transduced with TPA or a-UPA vectors, a series of 13 paired animal studies was carried out. For each of these studies, one collagen segment seeded with untransduced ECs (n=13) and a second collagen segment seeded with an equivalent number of TPA-transduced ECs (n=8), or a-UPAtransduced ECs (n=5), was placed in the exteriorized shunt of the same animal. Platelet deposition on collagen segments seeded with untransduced ECs was 1.98±0.69x109 platelets at 60 minutes (compared with 3.20±1.09x109 on unseeded segments; P=.003); fibrin accumulation on collagen segments was not affected by seeding with untransduced ECs (1.09±0.39 mg compared with 1.14±0.83 mg fibrin for unseeded segments; P=.5). Untransduced ECs significantly reduced platelet deposition but not fibrin accumulation in the propagated tails, that is, from 10.8±5.26x109 to 6.09±3.31x109 platelets (P=.014) and from 1.94±1.40 mg to 1.72±1.37 mg fibrin (P=.1).
Overexpression of TPA by transduced
ECs exhibited local antithrombotic
effects on platelet and fibrin accumulation (Fig 3 through
5![]()
![]()
and
Table 2
) compared with the effects of untransduced ECs
seeded onto collagen segments at equivalent density and interposed
sequentially in the same AV shunts. TPA-transduced ECs reduced
platelet deposition on the collagen segments from
2.05±0.47x109 platelets to
1.13±0.82x109 (P=.021;
P=.026 by
repeated measures ANOVA). Real-time images of platelet
deposition on representative grafts seeded with either
TPA-transduced or untransduced cells are shown in Fig 3
.
Fibrin accumulation on the collagen segments was 0.55±0.21 compared
with 0.69±0.29 mg fibrin for untransduced ECs (P=.29).
Platelet deposition was also significantly decreased in the
propagated tail by TPA-transduced ECs (3.39±2.67x109
versus 6.06±3.4x109 platelets; P=.013;
P=.10 by repeated measures ANOVA). Fibrin accumulation in
the thrombus tails was 0.62±0.55 compared with 1.31±1.11 mg
fibrin
(P=.07). It is notable that although the magnitudes of the
mean decrements in platelet and fibrin deposition by the
TPA-transduced cells were not identical (approximately 50% for
platelet deposition on both segments and tails as well as fibrin
accumulation on tails; 25% for fibrin deposition on the collagen
segment) in all cases, platelet and fibrin deposition decreased in
concert. Assuming that the 95% confidence limits of the mean
decrements extend 2 SEM, the magnitudes of the decrements were not
significantly different.
|
|
|
|
Vector-driven expression of a-UPA by
transduced ECs also produced
local antithrombotic effects compared with the effects of untransduced
ECs (Fig 4
and 5
and Table 3
).
a-UPAtransduced ECs reduced both platelet
deposition and fibrin accumulation on collagen segments, that is,
platelets decreased from 1.87±1.0x109 to
1.14±0.53x109 platelets (P=.16;
P=.079 by repeated measures ANOVA), and fibrin accumulation
on collagen segments fell from 0.92±0.50 to 0.32±0.11 mg
(P=.039). In the propagated tail, platelet accumulation
was reduced by a-UPAtransduced ECs to
3.86±3.06x109
compared with 6.15±3.7x109 platelets for
untransduced ECs (P=.022; P=.021 by repeated
measures ANOVA). Fibrin accumulation in the propagated tail was
1.32±0.57 mg compared with 2.37±1.61 mg fibrin for untransduced
ECs
(P=.12). Again, as detailed above for the TPA-transduced
cells, decrements in fibrin and platelet accumulation on the
segments and grafts were observed, although the magnitudes of
individual reductions were not always of significant, uniform
difference.
|
The levels of TPA or UPA antigen failed to change in blood
samples
collected immediately distal to the EC-bearing thrombogenic segments
compared with levels in blood sampled proximal to the segments (Tables
2
and 3
; P>.46 for all comparisons).
The absence of
detectable increases in the levels of plasminogen
activators across the devices bearing transduced ECs versus
untransduced ECs indicates that the small numbers of attached
transduced ECs enhanced only local thrombolysis.
Moreover, because there was no detectable increase in systemic plasma
levels of D-dimer, a specific biochemical marker of ongoing
fibrinolysis (P>.48 for all comparisons),
the local thrombolytic effects failed to produce
detectable systemic evidence of increased fibrinolytic activity.
Measurements of Thrombus Formation In Vivo
Plasma biochemical
tests of in vivo thrombosis were performed on
peripheral blood collected before and 60 minutes after
interposing collagen segments in AV shunts (Tables 2
and
3
). For
collagen segments seeded with untransduced ECs, the elevations in the
60-minute values of FPA and TAT were typical of those produced by
thrombus forming locally (threefold to fivefold increases;
P<.001 in both cases). Increases were also observed in
plasma levels of ß-thromboglobulin and
platelet factor 4, platelet-specific proteins secreted
during thrombus formation, that is, from 6.6±2.2 to 21±17 and
from
2.6±1.0 to 15±13, respectively (threefold- to sixfold increases;
P<.05 in both cases). Similar results were obtained with
collagen segments seeded with ECs transduced with the TPA and a-UPA
vectors (Tables 2
and 3
). No significant
differences were detected
between 60-minute plasma values measured for FPA, TAT, or
D-dimer during experiments comparing untransduced ECs
versus ECs transduced with either TPA or a-UPA vectors (Tables
2
and 3
;
P>.5 for all comparisons). Thus, unlike the results of
platelet deposition and fibrin accumulation on seeded collagen
segments, none of these systemic plasma measurements of ongoing
thrombosis and fibrinolysis were sufficiently sensitive
to distinguish the antithrombotic effects of transduced ECs from those
of untransduced ECs. Similarly, none of these systemic plasma
measurements could distinguish the relative importance of inhibiting
thrombus formation (as determined by changes in FPA or TAT) from that
of increasing fibrinolysis (as determined by changes in
D-dimer) in the enhanced antithrombotic activity observed
with ECs overexpressing plasminogen
activators.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The observed decreases in thrombus accumulation are most likely explained by direct local enhancement of thrombolysis. Increases in plasminogen activatordependent fibrinolysis may reduce thrombus formation by four potential mechanisms: (1) direct reduction in fibrin content, (2) diminished retention of activated platelets to fibrin, (3) inhibition of fibrinogen-dependent platelet recruitment by early fibrinolytic cleavage products, and (4) decreased binding of thrombin to fibrin.37 38 While systemic markers of thrombosis and fibrinolysis were measured to help discriminate among these mechanisms, they failed to provide insight into the relative importance of these putative mechanisms.
It is likely that the success of this model in limiting thrombogenesis as well as the absence of detectable alterations in plasma markers of thrombosis and fibrinolysis reflect the exquisite localization of the enhanced thrombolytic effect. In the present experimental system, overexpressed plasminogen activators are either anchored to the cell surface or are secreted into the slow moving, poorly diffusible luminal boundary layer.39 Within this boundary layer, the secreted plasminogen activators may further localize their effects by interacting with specific cell surface receptors40 or forming fibrin. We conclude that fibrinolysis is enhanced within this thin boundary layer and that indirect blood markers of increased fibrinolysis are not sufficiently modified to produce changes that are detectable by traditional blood sampling techniques.
The two plasminogen activator constructs tested in this study, wild-type TPA and anchored urokinase, produced similar antithrombotic effects. This outcome is concordant with in vitro findings using cultured ECs transduced with these constructs to activate plasminogen in situ.22 Of note, concerns based on data contained in these and other in vitro studies of transduced ECs19 that wild-type TPA would be ineffective in vivo due to inactivation by EC-derived PAI-1 appear to be unfounded. The present data support the view that serpin-resistant TPA variants41 42 offer no advantage over wild-type TPA except when massive excesses of PAI-1 are present, such as in EC culture systems22 43 or in vivo after injecting very large amounts of PAI-1.44 Specific testing of genetic constructs expressing serpin-resistant plasminogen activators in the present in vivo system would directly address this question.
It is important to emphasize both the strengths and the limitations of the experimental system used. An important strength is the use of a well-characterized nonhuman primate model of mural thrombosis. Baboons were chosen for this study because (1) baboons exhibit thrombotic and vascular response mechanisms closely simulating humans; (2) this particular thrombosis model is well characterized, reproducible, and quantitative, allowing detection of focal antithrombotic effects; and (3) as in humans, the formation of thrombus is abolished by either TPA or urokinase in this species.27 45 46 Accordingly, we believe that the results can reasonably be extrapolated to human thrombosis and fibrinolysis.
There are at least two significant limitations of the experimental system. First, while in the present study the period of observation was 60 minutes, it is theoretically possible that thrombo-occlusive events might develop many hours or days later. Realizing long-term persistence of these antithrombotic benefits will depend on both the ability of the transduced cells to survive in vivo and the capacity of these cells to continue secreting significant levels of recombinant gene products. In vitro, retrovirally transduced baboon endothelial cells express stable levels of recombinant gene products for several weeks (data not shown). However, data addressing the in vivo persistence of seeded EC and the continued ability of these seeded cells to express recombinant genes are more equivocal. Wilson et al18 demonstrated that transduced canine endothelial cells seeded onto Dacron grafts survived and continued to express a recombinant gene for at least 5 weeks, but the more recent results of Conte et al15 show that the level of recombinant gene expression from rabbit EC decays significantly within 1 week of reimplantation in vivo. Data from human trials of implantation of prosthetic devices seeded with autologous untransduced EC provide indirect evidence that seeded EC survive for at least 30 days and potentially as long as 3 years in vivo.47 48 It is apparent from these data that long-term trials testing the hypothesis that seeded, transduced EC can survive in vivo for prolonged periods of time are essential in defining the ultimate clinical promise of the short-term antithrombotic benefits demonstrated in the present study.
A second significant limitation of our data is that we compared the effects of transduced and untransduced ECs at subconfluent density, with contiguous exposure of thrombogenic collagen. This strategy was used because previous experiments showed that confluent coverage of collagen segments with untransduced ECs abolished thrombus accumulation,49 rendering a confluent system unable to distinguish any additional antithrombotic effects mediated by elevated levels of plasminogen activators. However, mechanical interventional procedures, such as angioplasty and endarterectomy, produce variably complete denudation with adjacent largely intact endothelium and therefore comprise a clinical correlate with the experimental model. Because plasminogen activators are secreted directly into the slow-moving, poorly diffusible luminal boundary layer, the attachment of transduced ECs onto such denuded endovascular surfaces could be expected to produce significant thrombolytic benefits. Thus, genetic modification of ECs immediately upstream from these thrombogenic sites is predicted to reduce acute thrombo-occlusive events and improve late patency.
In summary, the present findings support the approach of establishing transduced ECs at sites of mechanical vascular injury or on luminal surfaces of implanted chronic cardiovascular grafts. Additionally, EC gene transfer may prove to be an effective targeting strategy for delivering interventional molecules locally at sites of denuding vascular injury without incurring possible adverse effects and without the commitment of resources required for systemic therapies using the same molecules.
| Selected Abbreviations and Acronyms |
|---|
|
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received September 20, 1994; revision received June 13, 1995; accepted August 29, 1995.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S.K. Payeli, R. Latini, C. Gebhard, A. Patrignani, U. Wagner, T.F. Luscher, and F.C. Tanner Prothrombotic Gene Expression Profile in Vascular Smooth Muscle Cells of Human Saphenous Vein, but Not Internal Mammary Artery Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol., April 1, 2008; 28(4): 705 - 710. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Zaitsev, K. Danielyan, J.-C. Murciano, K. Ganguly, T. Krasik, R. P. Taylor, S. Pincus, S. Jones, D. B. Cines, and V. R. Muzykantov Human complement receptor type 1-directed loading of tissue plasminogen activator on circulating erythrocytes for prophylactic fibrinolysis Blood, September 15, 2006; 108(6): 1895 - 1902. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
F. Sharif, K. Daly, J. Crowley, and T. O'Brien Current status of catheter- and stent-based gene therapy Cardiovasc Res, November 1, 2004; 64(2): 208 - 216. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. G. Melo, M. Gnecchi, A. S. Pachori, D. Kong, K. Wang, X. Liu, R. E. Pratt, and V. J. Dzau Endothelium-Targeted Gene and Cell-Based Therapies for Cardiovascular Disease Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol., October 1, 2004; 24(10): 1761 - 1774. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Wen, S. Graf, P. G. Massey, and D. A. Dichek Improved Vascular Gene Transfer With a Helper-Dependent Adenoviral Vector Circulation, September 14, 2004; 110(11): 1484 - 1491. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L.G Melo, M Gnecchi, A.S Pachori, K Wang, and V.J Dzau Gene- and cell-based therapies for cardiovascular diseases: current status and future directions Eur. Heart J. Suppl., September 1, 2004; 6(suppl_E): E24 - E35. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
J.-C. Murciano, S. Muro, L. Koniaris, M. Christofidou-Solomidou, D. W. Harshaw, S. M. Albelda, D. N. Granger, D. B. Cines, and V. R. Muzykantov ICAM-directed vascular immunotargeting of antithrombotic agents to the endothelial luminal surface Blood, May 15, 2003; 101(10): 3977 - 3984. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Falkenberg, C. Tom, M. B. DeYoung, S. Wen, R. Linnemann, and D. A. Dichek Increased expression of urokinase during atherosclerotic lesion development causes arterial constriction and lumen loss, and accelerates lesion growth PNAS, August 6, 2002; 99(16): 10665 - 10670. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Ai Kim, C. C. Hedrick, Dangci Xie, and M. J. Fisher Adenoviral-Mediated Transfer of Tissue Plasminogen Activator Gene into Brain Capillary Endothelial Cells In Vitro Angiology, September 1, 2001; 52(9): 627 - 634. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Golino, P. Cirillo, P. Calabro', M. Ragni, D. D'Andrea, E. V. Avvedimento, F. Vigorito, N. Corcione, F. Loffredo, and M. Chiariello Expression of exogenous tissue factor pathway inhibitor in vivo suppresses thrombus formation in injured rabbit carotid arteries J. Am. Coll. Cardiol., August 1, 2001; 38(2): 569 - 576. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |